Wrap Up: CAA Pop Culture Book Club - Fall 2026

20 Nov 2026 9:09 AM | Kristin MacDonough (Administrator)

On November 12, seven CAA community members gathered on Zoom to discuss Awful Archives: Conspiracy Theory, Rhetoric, and Acts of Evidence by Jenny Rice (April 2020, 226 pages). After introductions, each person shared their main takeaways from the book, and then the floor opened up to responses and discussion. Common takeaways: a sensible argument is not often the best way to confront conspiracy theories and everyone enjoyed the personal stories from the author. We also felt the book provided a practical perspective on how to engage with personal connections who may support conspiracy theories. In short: you don’t!

Most folks found there was a good balance of personal narrative, academic research, and rhetorical theory throughout the book. Someone noted they appreciated the author being upfront about their own bias with regard to the personal narrative. The book was published in April 2020, so many attendees wondered how Rice might have approached the conspiracy theories surrounding COVID-19, the 2020 presidential election, the advent of AI, and other events that have happened since. 

We discussed how it’s possible that archival proof is not always definitive towards proving or disproving a theory. It was curious that the role of archivists was rarely mentioned, but no one felt this detracted from the book or the research. Someone noted, and many agreed, that the book expanded their vision of an archive and helped them think differently about how archives are created, accessed, and utilized by different communities. An interesting concept from the book was how the intangible is something that could be collected and used as evidence, the most interesting example being laughter. 

CAA Recommended? (5) readers Recommend, (1) reader Strongly Recommends, and (1) reader indicated Neutral / On the fence.

Keep an eye out in early 2027 for the next book club announcement! We’ll be gathering book suggestions for Spring 2027 (Fiction) for members to vote on soon after. If you have book suggestions now–or any questions about CAA Pop Culture Book Club–please email kristin.macdonough@gmail.com.

 

                 Contact CAA at info@chicagoarchivists.org

                 © Chicago Area Archivists

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software